Modeling Social Mechanisms: Mechanism-Based Explanations and Agent-Based Modeling in the Social Sciences
نویسنده
چکیده
An increasing number of philosophers of social sciences and of social scientists are getting interested in the relevance of mechanism-based explanations (MBE) in the social sciences. According to MBE, we explain a phenomenon by revealing the mechanism(s) responsible for its occurrence. In the social sciences, MBE has been particularly endorsed by analytical sociology. According to several proponents of analytical sociology but also to scholars from other disciplines, agent-based models (ABM) are a particularly relevant tool to produce MBE. Indeed, it is sometimes argued that to build an ABM and to use a mechanismbased reasoning is the same thing. This article evaluates the relevance of ABM to representing (social) mechanisms. It emphasizes the difficulties surrounding the representation of a particular form of social mechanisms I call “institutional mechanisms”, where the behavior of the social system and of its components (the social agents) are determined by institutional objects such as norms or conventions. I show that the implementation of the downward effect of an institutional element in an ABM calls for particular scrutiny. In particular, a theory of social institutions independent of the model is likely to be needed to implement the institutional object through the microspecifications of the model. I conclude that agent-based modeling cannot fully substitute to social theory.
منابع مشابه
Simulation of The Impact of Income Distribution on Social Unrest Using Agent-based Modeling Approach
Abstract Poverty and various forms of inequality, including class, gender, racial, and ethnic inequalities, are caused by imbalances of power relations and make society prone to social instability and unrest; Inequalities that are by-products of the growing power imbalances between the rich and the poor. The problems of poverty and inequality are inextricably linked to powerful economic and p...
متن کاملPeer Pressure in Smoking and its Impact on Social Welfare; A Study Using Agent-based Modeling and Simulation
Many people die each year due to smoking. Social pressures, such as peer pressure, which are manifested in one's interactions with his/her peers, are from very effective factors in people's tendency to smoke. In this research, it was attempted to study and analyze peer pressure in smoking and its impact on some of the welfare indicators including mortality number due to starvation, wealth avera...
متن کاملPeer Pressure in Smoking and its Impact on Social Welfare; A Study Using Agent-based Modeling and Simulation
Many people die each year due to smoking. Social pressures, such as peer pressure, which are manifested in one's interactions with his/her peers, are from very effective factors in people's tendency to smoke. In this research, it was attempted to study and analyze peer pressure in smoking and its impact on some of the welfare indicators including mortality number due to starvation, wealth avera...
متن کاملA review of agent-based modeling (ABM) concepts and some of its main applications in management science
We live in a very complex world where we face complex phenomena such as social norms and new technologies. To deal with such phenomena, social scientists often use reductionism approach where they reduce them to some lower-lever variables and model the relationships among them through a scheme of equations. This approach that is called equation based modeling (EBM) has some basic weaknesses in ...
متن کاملConceptual Agent based Modeling in Supply Chain: An Economic Perspective
Abstract: The implementation of government legislation, social responsibility, environmental concerns regarding the reduction of waste, hazardous material and other consumer residuals have made the competition between the firms stricter than ever and nowadays firms that want to survive need a more productive and innovative approach toward the financial aspects of their businesses.his pape...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2013